I have been wanting to review a few programs that we used last year, but this is the first one I've gotten around to. For 8th grade history, Holly used Beautiful Feet history. Because I felt it was light on literature compared to what we were used to, I chose Elizabeth Kamath's Lightning Lit & Comp as an additional literature course.

The curriculum consists of two books in notebook binders. The student's book is large and includes twelve chapters planned to cover two semesters. Each chapter contains a brief author bio, a short list of items to watch for while reading, recommended vocabulary lists, several comprehension questions, two literary lessons relating to a particular writing style or element, and several suggested writing exercises. The second half of the student's book contains a variety of workbook pages for each chapter, to be completed following the reading and literary lessons. Most of these I felt were worthwhile, although we skipped the busywork word search and crossword puzzle in each chapter.
The total cost for the teacher's guide and student book was about $65. It was not necessary for me to buy additional books, as I was able to find everything at my library.
Lightning Lit was an excellent choice for our school year. The book selections were not what I would have otherwise used; and Holly, for the most part, enjoyed them. Several of the readings were short stories or poems from Harold Bloom's Stories and Poems for Extremely Intelligent Children of All Ages, authored by G.K. Chesterton, Christina Rosetti, Lewis Carroll, Walt Whitman, Ralph Waldo Emerson. The books, both fiction and non-fiction, included A Day of Pleasure by Isaac Bashevis Singer, Dickens' A Christmas Carol, and Tolkien's The Hobbitt.
(I have to admit I was shocked to discover how much TREVOR knew A Christmas Carol--apparently from watching the MICKEY MOUSE cartoon. Sigh. I suppose I can never say that Disney didn't teach us anything...)
Early on, I told Holly she could opt out of one book throughout the course, and after she began reading Treasure Island, she decided that would be the one to skip.
What I liked:
- The book selections. For so long, I've handpicked books that fit both our curriculum and my daughter's tastes. This was great exposure to a variety of writing.
- Ease of use. Holly easily picked this up to do on her own, yet it was for me to pick up at the end of the day to later review with her. With me working part time this year, ease of use for both of us was crucial.
- Flexibility! It's easy to adapt the workload to fit the student, skipping over any workbook pages, based on what the student already knows (or may not need to cover). While there are guidelines on what should be completed each week, I had no problem adapting to fit us. I think we began several weeks into the school year, and we completed about 80% of the book.
- The lessons. They make the student think. These are not fill-in-the-blank answers.
- The writing exercises. Each chapter includes several writing exercises, and the student is told to choose just one. You can assign an additional exercise if there is time. Many of the exercises build on what the student has worked on earlier in the lesson. It was easy for Holly to choose the one that best fit her.
- The variety. Over the course of the year, students study and then apply a wide variety of skills, including identifying bias, taking notes, rewriting source material, writing ballads and free verse, and creating allegory.
What I didn't like:
It's minor, really. While the teacher's guide lays out lesson plans in an easy-to-read, check-the-box format, it didn't include any mention of reviewing the comprehension and discussion questions with the student. I NEED this reminder. It was easy to fix; I just penciled it in for each chapter. But it's a relevant part of the study to not include!
Lightning Lit has courses that continue through high school. I wish we were continuing to use it; it worked that well. Instead, we'll be using Notgrass-- partially because of how much it reminds me of Lightning Lit. The additional appeal of Notgrass is that it combines history, literature and Bible. If Notgrass doesn't work out, I'll definitely be back considering Lightning Lit. Meanwhile, I'll be planning to use this 8th grade book for Trevor in a few years. This was definitely a HIT at our house!